Is it Time to Tell Maple Leafs GM Brian Burke You Were Wrong?

10 Comments
Join the Conversation
Phil Kessel: Early 2011-12 NHL Pionts Leader. - Photo by Mat Boulton
Phil Kessel: Early 2011-12 NHL Pionts Leader. - Photo by Mat Boulton
He may have done it, Brian Burke. It's early in the NHL season but the Toronto Maple Leafs keep winning. Is it time to admit we were wrong about him?

It may be time for some NHL fans - including members of the Leaf Nation - to acknowledge the egg on their face and prepare to say something to Toronto Maple Leaf GM Brian Burke they did not think they'd have to say. The words are simple, most, nay virtually all of us, have said them before.

They must prepare to say these 3 words - 'I was wrong.'

Yes it is early and after the Leafs 4-1 win in Columbus on Nov. 4, 2011, with rookie Ben Scrivens in goal, they were still only 13 games into the 2011-12 campaign (or 15.8 percent of the season). But never mind the date, Toronto's 9-3-1 record is made all the more legitimate by the way the team is playing. They are working hard and getting contributions up and down the line-up. And they're consistent and motivated.

How's this: the Leafs have yet to lose 2 in a row this season. Yes, early but the Vancouver Canucks, Boston Bruins and Pittsburgh Penguins, to name just a few, can't boast that. They also have yet to be shutout, something that happened last year as often as a John Tortorella meltdown (in 2010-11 they were shutout 5 times in their first 22 games).

Maple Leafs Third in NHL Goal Scoring

At this early juncture Brian Burke's team is actually in first place overall and they've scored 45 goals, second highest in the NHL. Last year on their way to finishing 10th in the Eastern Conference, 8 points out of the playoffs, the team wound up 23rd in the league in scoring with a paltry 218 goals.

The scoring leader for the 2010-11 Leafs was Phil Kessel with 64 points, 32 goals and 32 assists, good enough for 36th in the NHL (he was a -20). So far this season their scoring leader is again Kessel and his 10 goals and 11 assists for 21 points has him in first place in point scoring (he's a plus10). If it keeps up fans will have to admit to being wrong about the Tyler Seguin deal, too.

Brian Burke: Refused to Fire Ron Wilson

A lot of Leaf fans were calling for Brian Burke to be fired over the past two seasons, despite the fact he'd only been hired late in 2008. They were hoping coach Ron Wilson would go with him. Not seeing playoff hockey in 7 seasons tends to make the faithful a bit trigger happy.

But if fans do not now admit they were wrong then surely the time is coming soon that they must. Fine, give the Leafs another dozen games to screw up before those apologies. But if they keep winning at this clip, or close to it, the time will soon come to eat humble hockey pie.

Some fans have seen enough. The work ethic, goaltending, the scoring, trades and signings (not that defence yet, though) is real. Brian Burke has assembled a talented team with great young players and veteran skill and toughness. Which is why some fans are ready to admit the problem was not the GM and all he needed was time. He got it and he just may have done it.

So, Brian Burke, I was wrong.

Canadian actor Hondro writes about many subjects., James N. Hondro

Marcus Hondro - Marcus Hondro is a wide-ranging writer and actor based near Vancouver, Canada.

rss
Advertisement
Leave a comment

NOTE: Because you are not a Suite101 member, your comment will be moderated before it is viewable.
Submit
What is 0+2?

Comments

Nov 3, 2011 4:06 AM
Guest :
Where's the parade? 12 games into a season does not erase 6 YEARS of fertility! Win a playoff round and then I'll admit I was wrong...
Nov 3, 2011 9:50 AM
Guest :
Yes, BB, too, I was wrong. You have done well over the past few years to assemble a quality team. However, with bottom-three goaltending (again!) and league-worst special teams (again and again!), Ron Wilson continues to prove he's not up to the task of coaching the Leafs. Until he goes and is replaced by soemone who can properly coatch these kdis, your efforsts will amount to nothing and we can forget the playoffs (again and again and again!)

Note to guest -- it's futility! Fertility is whole nuther thing! LOL!
Nov 3, 2011 10:10 AM
Guest :
Sorry, Marcus, but the notion that an 8-3-1 record is enough to assess Burke's success is like saying the Red Wings are a terrible organization because of their recent poor start. I appreciate your optimism, though :)
Nov 3, 2011 10:43 AM
Guest :
I think you meant futility...
Nov 3, 2011 10:49 AM
Marcus Hondro :
The point about the Red Wings is a good one, they're strong despite their start. But this start means something for the Leafs. Last year they tried to pull this off but after 4 straight wins to open the season, followed by an overtime loss, the wheels fell off. They haven't this time. And with the way they're capable of playing after the all-star break?

They'll make the playoffs.
Nov 3, 2011 1:01 PM
Guest :
I agree. They've done a good job this year so far. The real test will come when/if they do lose two games in a row, and how they bounce back from that. There are things they need to work on, like special teams (mind you PP is MUCH better) but you can't knock:
- Work ethic
- Consistency
- Never Say Die attitude
- Depth
- Speed

Work ethic alone is the biggest improvement I see from the days before Burke. That team that missed the playoffs so much had a very different attitude and culture then this one. And for that, you have to credit both Burke and Wilson.. they've created a system that preaches accountability.. that's all I ever wanted. Long gone are the days when vets sign in Toronto as a nice way to end thier careers... if your not gonna play HARD, this is not the place for you.
Nov 3, 2011 7:31 PM
Guest :
The fact is there they are now 9 -3 -1 in the young season. They are working hard and, with exception of Philadelphia and Boston, they have been a bounce away from being 11-2. Yes there is a problem with the PP but overall leaf fans have to be over the moon with the start of to this year. I was waiting for the wheels to come off my little blue and white wagon ( in view of what happened last year) but I sense a totally different attitude and motivation this year.
Nov 4, 2011 6:16 AM
Guest :
Fertility? Really?
Mar 22, 2012 5:03 PM
Guest :
you were wrong to say you were wrong.
Mar 24, 2012 12:21 PM
Marcus Hondro :
Yes, you're right, I was wrong. I've written a piece on Digital Journal that addresses that. It's too bad, it was, as we all know, looking good until some time in mid-February or so. Burke should go, he's had his chance!!!!
10 Comments
Advertisement
Advertisement