Obama's 2012 Budget Draft Proposes a Border Tax for Canadians

5 Comments
Join the Conversation
Obama's budget draft proposes a border tax for Canadian visitors - Photo by Wikimedia Commons
Obama's budget draft proposes a border tax for Canadian visitors - Photo by Wikimedia Commons
President Barack Obama's draft federal budget has a proposal to levy a $5.50 passenger inspection fee for Canadians traveling across the U.S. border.

Washington D.C. February 16, 2011 - U.S. President Barack Obama submitted the draft federal budget to Congress with a proposal to impose a $5.50 fee for Canadians crossing the border by air or by sea. If approved the new border tax, or "passenger inspection fee" would bring an extra $110 million to Federal coffers.

Visitors from Canada, Mexico and several Caribbean countries had to pay a similar passenger inspection fee back in 1994 under NAFTA but were exempted in 1997 at the insistence of a group of congressmen who argued that it was bad for cross-border business. However, Obama's draft budget proposal for fiscal year 2012 proposes to lift this exemption. Although President Obama and Canadian Prime Minister Stephen Harper recently met to discuss ways to improve border flow and trade, as well as establishing a national security perimeter, the draft budget proposal came as a surprise to many Canadians and is sure to be debated.

Visiting Tax for Canadians is "Troubling"

Things haven't gotten any easier for Canadian travelers since 2009 when an entry law to the U.S. required Canadians to carry passports. The new proposed fee would not apply to Canadians driving across the border. Approximately 16 million Canadians fly across the U.S. border each year and the proposed fee would help pay for increased U.S. border security. "The raising of any fees on the Canada-U.S. border is troubling" said Birgit Matthiesen of the Canadian Manufacturers and Exporters, Canada's largest trade and industry association. Colin Robertson, a fellow of the Canadian Defence and Foreign Affairs INstitute who was part of the team that negotiated the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) with the United States said, "They will be looking everywhere to find money...given the desperate financial situation the States is in...we should make a joint cause with Mexico."

Proposed Budget Draft Plans to Bring in Fresh Revenue to Pay Debt

After one of the worst recessions in years President Obama plans to rebuild the American economy by cutting wasteful spending. With the clear message that Americans should live within their means, the budget is about "making tough choices on some things we cannot afford."

The $3.7 trillion plan proposes to trim or eliminate about 200 federal programs. New budget priorities include spending on education, energy and medical research. The budget proposal has Obama relying on new taxes to improve the government's finances in the long term with $1.6 trillion in new revenues, such as the resuscitating the passenger fee that was suppressed in 1997.

Giovanna De Gennaro, Photograph by Paola De Gennaro

Giovanna De Gennaro - Giovanna is a Canadian citizen who has travelled and worked abroad. She speaks four languages and has worked as an EFL teacher in Italy. ...

rss
Advertisement
Leave a comment

NOTE: Because you are not a Suite101 member, your comment will be moderated before it is viewable.
Submit
What is 10+9?

Comments

Feb 19, 2011 1:18 PM
Guest :
$110 million that will never be used as intended. Why should I pay for a mistake another country made?
Feb 19, 2011 7:26 PM
Guest :
A better deal on border controls!

The trades, values and common civilization of United States and Canada are linked like in no others countries. A threat to one of them is a threat to the other.

Actually, $1.6 billion worth of goods is crossing between the shared border daily but there are major security and control problems at the U.S.-Canada border where only 50 kilometres of the 6,400-kilometre are properly monitored. During the 1990s, the rapid growth of Canada-US trade was a major force of economic growth in Canada. It eroded after 911. The bilateral North American Security Perimeter talks is potentially historic and a wide-ranging agreement with the aim of identifying, preventing, and countering violent extremism. In exchange for greater cooperation the two governments will ease the flow of cross-border traffic and boost Canada-U.S. trade. The talks should take place in public so that everybody can see what is on the table. The North American Security Perimeter will not only facilitate trade but will give Canada increased influence in Washington, and place it in a unique strategic relationship with the US. If it is not done the proposal by Washington contained in the 2012 budget to collect a $5.50 levy on all Canadians entering the U.S. by air and sea can be only the beginning.
Feb 20, 2011 8:25 AM
Guest :
If Obama is afraid to take on the financial institutions that caused the mess the usa is in ,then I guess the cowardly way is to make us pay at the border, IF WE CROSS. Just on principal I won't and I hope others think the same way. Sorry Buffalo, call your congressman.
Feb 20, 2011 6:25 PM
Guest :
As a Canadian, I would be more than willing to pay a $5.50 passenger inspection fee. Our good neighbour, the United States of America is in financial dire straights -- if your neighbour was in trouble and you could lend a helping hand wouldn't you! Let us lend a helping hand to a friend in need. JCKCanada
Mar 2, 2011 2:42 PM
Guest :
Seems a step backward to make the border a little harder to cross instead of working to eliminate it.
5 Comments
Advertisement
Advertisement