The following false statements are just three examples of inaccurate interpretations that persist regarding the three/fifths compromise :
- the 3/5s compromise of 1788. . . enshrined slavery in the United States Constitution
- African Americans in this country were considered only 3/5s human at one point in history.
- “In the original U.S. Constitution, I was only three-fifths of a person." --Condoleezza Rice
When a person as knowledgeable and sophisticated as Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice gets a historical fact so wrong, it demonstrates how deeply some errors persist throughout the culture.
Representation, Not Degree of Humanity
The delegates to the Constitutional Convention met in Philadelphia from May 25 to September 17, 1787. Their original reason for meeting was to revise the Articles of Confederation, which had proved too weak to address the issues that faced the country in its independence from England. James Madison and Alexander Hamilton had been convinced that they would have to scrap those Articles and start fresh, and that is what they did.
A controversy arose about how to write the sections on representation in the Senate and House of Representatives. The states with large populations wanted representation based solely on population, while the states with small populations wanted each state to have equal representation. They settled on a solution that would satisfy both large and small-populated states: each state would send two representatives, Senators, to the upper house, and the number of members sent to the lower House of Representatives would be based on population.
Even after this compromise was worked out, another problem still existed. Northern states insisted that counting slaves, who did not vote or pay taxes, would give the South an unfair advantage in representation. Southern slave states, of course, wanted this advantage.
To What Does Three/Fifths Refer?
The compromise that settled this dispute is now called the Three/Fifths Compromise, which stipulates that three/fifths of the slave population would be counted for purposes of representation. Three/fifths does not, nor did it then, designate the degree of humanity that a black person has. The framers of the Constitution did not “enshrine” slavery in that document; they actually used language that would allow for the demise of slavery, which they knew would happen, because they knew slavery was an evil institution.
In Article 1, Section 2, Paragraph 3 of the United States Constitution, the three/fifths compromise is stated:
"Representatives and direct Taxes shall be apportioned among the several States which may be included within this Union, according to their respective Numbers, which shall be determined by adding to the whole Number of free Persons, including those bound to Service for a Number of Years, and excluding Indians not taxed, three fifths of all other Persons." (emphasis added)
The "three fifths of all other Persons" refers to the slave population as a whole, not to the humanity of each individual.
Readers will notice that no term such as "slavery," "slaves," "Negroes," or "Blacks" is used to designate those in the United States of African descent. The framers of the Constitution knew that the institution of slavery could not endure, but the country urgently needed a government that would provide strong leadership in securing the rights for citizens and a government that would bring unity to the sprawling land.
If those framers had deemed Africans only three/fifths human, they would not have hesitated to write that distinction in their founding document. Some of the framers maintained plantations and owned slaves; thus, they knew that Blacks were fully human. However, it was not feasible to emancipate slaves at the same time they were desperately trying to formulate a document that would govern the country.
Sources:
- Pennsylvania Historical & Museum Commission, People, James Buchanan.
- Kathy Belge, Some Inspirational Words of the Day, Lesbian Life.
- Eric Zencey, "Is Condoleezza Rice Right to Say the Founders Believed Blacks Were Only 3/5ths of a Person?" History News Network.
Linda Sue Grimes - As a writer, researcher, and SRF devotee, Linda Sue Grimes has studied poetry and practiced Kriya Yoga for over thirty years..
Join the Conversation