Contents of Article
- About These Two Brands
- Leesa and Loom & Leaf Comparison
- And The Winning Mattress is …
- For Sleepers With Specific Needs
Two more door-front delivery mattresses go head-to-head. This time we are comparing Leesa, a popular mattress in a box, to Loom and Leaf. Saatva’s “Luxury Foam Mattress.” Not only are these two brands duking it out for who can provide the most comfortable night of sleep, but they also each do a lot to reduce their carbon footprint and keep things green.
So, which one of these two eco-friendly sleep companies will green light in this review? Let’s look at what each bed has to offer and then decide.
About These Two Brands
First, we’re going to take a quick stock of both brands.
Loom & Leaf Recap Full Review
What To Like
- White glove delivery and free setup.
- No off-gas or odor.
- Super heavy-duty 5-lb premium foam.
- Naturally fire-retardant organic cotton cover.
- They use cooling gel.
- Loom & Leaf has two firmness options.
What Not To Like
- If you like innerspring mattresses, you might not like the luxury, Tempur-Pedic-like feel.
- They are online only, so you can’t easily find a test product.
Loom and Leaf prides themselves on making a Luxury Foam bed that can compete with Tempur-Pedic at almost a 3rd of the cost. They also have gained trust as one of the mattress companies with the best customer service and are one of the eco-friendliest mattress companies around.
Loom and Leaf offer a 12-inch thick mattress comprised of 4 high-quality foam layers sourced only in the United States and a quilted cotton cover.
- 120-day trial period.
- Delivery and in-home installations are free.
- 15-year warranty
- Loom & Leaf beds are CertiPUR-US® certified.
- Recognized by Sustainable Furnishings Council.
- Loom & Leaf is guardin® certified
- Made with hypoallergenic materials that are non-toxic.
- Sourced and made in the United States.
Leesa Recap Full Review
What To Like
- They use a latex-like Avena® Foam.
- They create social initiatives.
- Great at reducing motion transfer.
- Leesa often runs $150 discounts.
- Can try their products in Pottery Barn.
What Not To Like
- There have been some off-gassing reports.
- Leesa lacks edge support.
Leesa is a big name in the bed-in-a-box industry. They created this mattress with their Universal Adaptive Feel™, and L&L have grown in popularity since launching as one of the first ‘bed in a box’ companies back in 2014.
Leesa uses a latex-like polyurethane called Avena® Foam with pin-core holes and an egg-shaped (convoluted) bottom surface to promote airflow for a ‘memory foam’ mattress that sleeps cool. Leesa is manufactured with three foam layers and stands 10 inches tall.
- They offer the industry-standard 100-night trial.
- Leesa is made in the USA.
- Arrives in a compressed box at your door.
- Leesa offers a standard 10-year limited warranty.
- They are leaders in environmental awareness.
Leesa and Loom & Leaf Comparison
We have already learned a lot about Leaf & Loom and Leesa mattresses. But how do they compare when we sit them side by side and consider all of their qualities?
How are Leesa and Loom & Leaf Similar
Neither Are Innerspring
Neither of these two beds uses any springs. Both Leesa and Loom & Leaf are ‘all-foam’ beds. So, if you are looking for that box-spring-mattress-type feel, neither of these sleep products will satisfy your needs. But if you are looking for that Luxury Memory Foam feel, or Latex Foam feel, these two will do the trick.
Both of these mattresses offer fantastic back support. Your spine was in mind when Loom & Leaf and Leesa designed these beds. They will therapeutically mold and contour to your body and fill gaps where needed so that your spine stays aligned.
Sleep testers on other Leesa reviews and testers on Loom & Leaf Reviews put both of these mattresses at around 7 out of 10 on a scale of 1 to 10 regarding firmness. That said, they are a little different. Most people found Leesa to rate at a 7, but Loom & Leaf has some 6s, and some 8s, some 7s for an average score of 7
Using seismic sensors to test how much energy transfers across the bed we find that both of these beds perform quite well. The Leesa performs a little bit better, but not so much so that you can call it a notable difference.
Being all-foam mattresses, neither will have the side support of an innerspring, but both offer a decent amount. You won’t feel like you are going to fall off the bed if your partner is Mr. or Mrs. Crazy Legs and hogs all of the bed, forcing you to sleep along the edge. Though, due to the super dense 5-pound foam used by Loom & Leaf, they do get the slight nod here.
How Leesa & Loom & Leaf are Different
Although the difference isn’t much, Loom and Leaf are around $100 more expensive. Plus, sometimes Leesa runs ‘pay now’ discounts that could put that difference into the two-hundred-dollar range.
Loom & Leaf builds their mattresses with a premium foam comfort layer that has a convoluted bottom surface and a proprietary cooling spinal gel throughout the middle of the bed where your torso would typically be. After this, they use a layer of premium USA made, ecologically-friendly, 5-lb, high-density foam. This foam is guaranteed not to off-gas or have an unpleasant odor.
They construct the base out of two layers of eco-friendly, breathable support foam that has channels for additional airflow. When you add this all up, you have a bed that is durable and give you plenty of support underneath all of that plush memory foam comfort.
Leesa uses a polyurethane foam that performs akin to latex foam. It has a springy response that allows you to sleep a little bit more on top of the mattress so that you can move naturally throughout the night and never have that ‘stuck in the bed’ feeling. The Avena® Foam comfort layer is perforated with pin-core holes, and egg-crate shaped to promote the needed airflow to keep your sleeping surface as fresh as a gentle spring breeze.
The other two foam layers are made from a two-inch thick memory foam layer in the middle that helps act as a transition between the Avena Foam and the denser six-inch base-layer foam that serves as the support and foundation of Leesa beds.
Loom & Leaf offers two different comfort levels; L&L Relaxed Firm and L&L Firm. Leesa only has the one model. This option gives Loom & Leaf customers an advantage because heavier back sleepers can choose the Firm for optimal full-length body support for their weight and sleep position and side-sleepers can choose the Relaxed Firm so that their hips and shoulders sink in just the right amount for maximum comfort.
Warranty & Shipping
The Loom & Leaf warranty is five years longer. The extended warranty tells us that L&L has at least 50% more faith in the durability of their product than Leesa. They also offer free in-home setup with their delivery.
Again, L&L goes a step further here. They take pride in their customer service and want you to be 100% sure that you are satisfied with their product. Their 120-day trial period is four full months for you to make up your mind without any risk. Leesa offers a commendable 100-night trial, and both will pick up returned mattresses free of charge.
How They Feel
Loom & Leaf feels like a luxury foam mattress. The gel foam comfort layer and the high-density memory foam layer are very slow to respond to pressure. The gradual manner in which these foams react is what gives them that perfect body-contouring feel and helps keep them from pushing back against pressure points.
Laying on the bed, you get that classic ‘sunk in’ memory foam feel. Although it isn’t difficult to change positions, you move around, the foam is slow to respond, so it doesn’t help you in your movement. This bed stands out for side sleepers. You don’t feel any pressure on your hips or shoulders while laying on your side.
Leesa has more bounce than L&L because of its faster responding latex-like foam. This feeling is quite the opposite of the Loom & Leaf, as the bed will assist your movement a little. The response also helps make this bed shine for back sleepers; you can feel the latex foam pushing up into your lumbar region to provide support while laying on your back.
Lab tests were completed for each of these mattresses. Researchers laid pressure mapping pads across the surface of the bed so that they could measure the hotspots of pressure and identify when and where you might see some potential discomfort.
Both mattresses performed equally well for back sleepers. But the Loom and Leaf shined for both side sleepers and stomach sleepers. The L&L had just a hair more pressure on the point of the hip, but much less all along the side and at the shoulders.
Leesa’s cover is a polyester blend that is very soft to the touch. It’s reasonably breathable but definitely thicker than other bed covers. This gives a high-quality aspect to it but may hamper the Avena® Foam layer’s cooling properties a tad.
Loom & Leaf uses soft and breathable, 100% organic cotton with thistle to create a naturally flame retardant cover. It has a quilted top with a thin layer of foam that gives it a little bit of added pressure relief right on top of the mattress and of course, that extra luxurious feel.
And The Winning Mattress is …
Loom & Leaf! Buy Online Now
We’re confident recommending Loom & Leaf as the best choice based on our analysis of key factors that an average, discerning mattress shopper would care most about.
When you look at the table below, it becomes quite clear. Loom and Leaf offer a better warranty, better sleep-trial, they will set your mattress up for you and the quality of materials used is downright better. Sure, they come in around 100 dollars more that Leesa, but for all the L&L offers, we think it is well worth it.
- Quality – Loom & Leaf
- Price – Leesa
- Reputation – Tie
- Sleep Trial – Loom & Leaf
- Warranty – Loom & Leaf
- Customer Support – Loom & Leaf
- Product Selection – Loom & Leaf
For Sleepers With Specific Needs
Side Sleepers: Choose Loom & Leaf
The pressure maps show precisely why side sleepers would prefer this bed over Leesa. There is much more pressure relief along the sleeper’s side and shoulders.
Stomach Sleepers: Choose Loom & Leaf
Many people point out what a great mattress L&L is for side sleepers, and it’s true. But really, this is a stomach sleepers bed! When we reviewed the pressure maps, there was almost no green marking slight pressure. There was certainly no yellow or red. It is almost like stomach sleepers are on an anti-gravity bed.
People with Back Pain: Choose Loom & Leaf
Luxury Foam beds are renowned for their ability to let your heavier parts sink just enough to keep your spine perfectly aligned. Loom & Leaf have committed themselves to researching and implementing sleep technologies that relieve pressure points and improve circulation. Increased blood flow to the spine and proper alignment will do wonders for back pain.
Heavy People: Choose Loom & Leaf
Heavier people can choose between the two different firmness levels. This is something that isn’t offered by Leesa. If you are bigger, or heavier, the L&L Firm will better support your weight and create the optimal sleeping situation for you.
Couples: Choose Loom & Leaf
One issue we found in reviews of Leesa was that a moderately heavy sleeper (200-lbs) would create a hill of sorts in the latex-like comfort layer of the Leesa mattress and cause the smaller sleeper to slide towards their partner. The L&L mattress is not responsive like latex foam so, this will not be an issue. Plus, the heavy-duty support foam provides better side support.
Through our research into Loom & Leaf, we have found that it genuinely is a luxury foam bed at an affordable price. A queen will run you $1099 and is comparable in quality to Tempur-Pedic mattresses that cost $2700.00. And with their 120-day money-back trial and free pickup, there is no reason not to move forward with Loom & Leaf if you want a Luxury Foam mattress.